In depth

Giftedness: intensity, complexity, time

Giftedness is a word heard more and more often in Italy, and it carries very different expectations. For some it suggests exceptional results, for others a struggle that is hard to explain. On this page we try to bring some order, with a view that is as objective as possible, and to say clearly what matters to us.

A small Rubik's cube resting on top of a larger one, with other colourful puzzles blurred in the background.
Photo by Fletcher Pride on Unsplash

What we mean

By giftedness we mean high cognitive abilities, which can show themselves in very different ways and do not always translate into exceptional results at school or at work. To understand it, we also look at the person's experience: how they learn, how they pursue their interests, how they live their relationships. Some profiles show deep questions, unexpected connections or strong emotional intensity; in others these traits take different forms, or do not appear at all. It can come with great passions and great effort, sometimes on the same day.

Giftedness is not, in itself, a learning disorder. Its relationship with neurodivergence, on the other hand, is debated: some approaches include it in this category, others prefer to keep it separate, partly because neurodivergence is not a diagnostic term and has no shared definition. What matters to us is recognising each person's characteristics and needs, without confusing giftedness with the conditions that may accompany it, such as ADHD, autism or specific learning disorders. We explain why we use this very word in Plusdotazione, high potential, giftedness: why words matter.

More than a number

For a long time giftedness was identified almost solely with an intelligence test score. From the 1940s to today, research and educational practice have proposed increasingly broad readings. Some look at the passage from abilities to talents, others at the meeting of ability, creativity and commitment, others still at inner experience and emotional development. There is no single, shared definition, and the discussion is still open. In the United States, for example, the National Association for Gifted Children speaks of students who perform, or have the capability to perform, at higher levels compared to others.

Tests remain a useful tool when interpreted by qualified professionals alongside other information. On their own, though, they do not tell who a person is or how they are doing. We do not adopt one model at the expense of the others: we hold together what the different perspectives have brought to light, and we state openly where we place our emphasis.

When timings do not match

One of the aspects most often described by those who study giftedness, and by those who live it, is uneven development. In some children cognitive abilities, everyday skills and emotional needs follow different timelines: a child may tackle complex questions with surprising ease and still need help organising their activities, coping with a disappointment or finding their place in a group.

These gaps can lead to misunderstandings when an advanced ability is expected to bring the same independence in every situation:

  • at school, where those who understand quickly are often assumed to be independent and calm as well;
  • in adulthood, at work and in relationships, when one feels out of step.

Naming this experience helps us look at it without blame.

When giftedness and difficulties meet

We speak of twice-exceptionality (2e) when giftedness occurs together with a specific learning disorder, ADHD, autism or other conditions. These profiles are hard to recognise: abilities can compensate for difficulties and hide them, or difficulties can overshadow abilities. The risk is that the person is only half seen.

Recognising both sides helps to identify the support a person needs while leaving room for their interests and abilities: difficulties call for specific attention, and so do opportunities to keep learning. It is a theme we follow closely, including in our collaborations.

At school, in Italy

A note from the Italian Ministry of Education (no. 562 of 3 April 2019) opened the possibility of including gifted students among those with special educational needs. It is up to the class council, or the teaching team in primary school, to decide whether to put a personalised plan in place. The debate on a dedicated law is ongoing: we wrote about it in A law for gifted students.

What matters to us

  • The person beyond the result: cognitive abilities tell only part of the story. Emotional wellbeing, relationships and the conditions in which a person learns deserve the same attention. When an emotion is felt with particular intensity, we understand it by listening to what the person tells us, before giving it an explanation.
  • Choices made together: everyone should be able to take part in the decisions that concern them, express interests and preferences, suggest alternatives and change their mind. In childhood this dialogue is built with the support of adults, who keep their educational responsibilities. A talent does not oblige anyone to turn every interest into a performance.
  • Respect for learning timelines: someone who understands quickly may, at other moments, need to go slowly. Going deeper, pausing or asking for support are part of learning. A pause, on its own, does not tell us what is happening: to understand it we need to look at the person and the context.

These are the same principles as our Inclusive education manifesto and the way we work, described on our About us page.

Keep exploring

Our reflections, the contributions to our column and our teaching materials are how these principles become practice.

Legal reference

Ministero dell'Istruzione, dell'Università e della Ricerca. (2019). Nota prot. n. 562 del 3 aprile 2019 [Note no. 562 of 3 April 2019].

← Back to home

Reading options